Built in 1890, the William Arnott House is a fully realized Queen Anne Victorian that retains its architectural confidence more than a century later. Positioned minutes from Lake Hopatcong, the house was sited to take advantage of elevation and light, with seasonal lake views that remain part of its original intent rather than a modern add-on.
The exterior announces itself with a wrap-around porch that leads into a proper entry hall—an increasingly rare feature—anchored by a grand oak staircase and original fireplace. Inside, the plan follows a traditional hierarchy of spaces. Formal living and dining rooms are defined, not merged, each framed by tall, floor-to-ceiling windows and their own fireplaces. These rooms were designed for both daily use and occasion, and they still read that way today.
The kitchen has been renovated with restraint, maintaining its role as a working room rather than overpowering the rest of the house. A center island, breakfast bar, coffee station, and updated appliances are integrated without erasing the home’s character, while a window looks out toward the private rear grounds.
The second floor is anchored by a primary suite that preserves its original fireplace and proportions, paired with a walk-in closet and an ensuite bath featuring a clawfoot soaking tub and walk-in shower. Two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a Juliet balcony complete the level. The third floor—often the most revealing space in a Victorian—offers three more bedrooms, a full bath, and flexible rooms that speak to the home’s original scale and long-term adaptability.
Set on just under three-quarters of an acre, the fenced grounds include multiple patios, an in-ground pool, and mature landscaping that provides privacy without isolation. A detached two-car garage completes the property. The house has been carefully maintained and updated over time, allowing modern systems to coexist with late-19th-century craftsmanship.
Within walking distance of Lake Hopatcong beaches, parks, and downtown Mount Arlington, this is a home that continues to function as it was intended: prominent, practical, and deeply rooted in its place.
🏛️ Property Details
🗓️ Built: 1890
🏠 Style: Queen Anne Victorian
📜 Historic Name: William Arnott House
📐 Living Space: 4,396 sq ft
🛏️ Bedrooms: 5
🛁 Bathrooms: 4
🌳 Lot Size: 0.71 acres
🌊 Views: Seasonal views of Lake Hopatcong
🏊 Exterior Features: In-ground pool, patios, fenced yard
🚗 Garage: Detached 2-car
📍 Address: 506 Windemere Ave, Mount Arlington Boro, NJ 07856
💰 Price: $999,000
👤 Listed by: Compass New Jersey, LLC
From Zillow
